tkeaton
Master Velocipede Alchemist
- Joined
- Mar 20, 2005
- Location
- Chattanooga
I've spoken with a few machine shops in my area about a project I am about to start and wanted to share the response I've received from one of them to see if I can get some additional opinions.
454, 4-bolt
Wanting to go to 467 (468 depending on what you want to call it)
Powerplant is going in a street truck/hotrod, will not be raced, will not be a "performance" engine. I want to do 467 because that's what I want to do, but don't have any power requirements or anything like that. This will be a weekend cruisemobile. Building it to take advantage of 1800-3000rpm range. Or something like that...
Shop A comes highly recommended, I've stopped and talked to them, pricing is great, turnaround is great, etc. Told them what I wanted, they said "Ok!"
Shop B also comes highly recommended, more of a race engine shop however. Stopped to chat, told them what I wanted, pricing is great, turnaround is a little slower (not a big deal.) The difference is that they strongly recommended only going .30 over to start. When asked about this, the response was something along the lines of build to .30 over the first time and then when I want to step it up, or when engine needs rebuilding/re-machining, then go .60 over. Something else along the lines of if .30 over goofs up, you still have room to go bigger. If it messes up at .60over, then block is toast, so start smaller then step up later or if problems develop.
Other than $ involved to machine twice, buy two sets of pistons/parts/etc, how much does the rest of their reasoning hold up?
Shouldn't I be comfortable with the machining the first time, from either shop, that the block won't be f'd if I go .60 the first time?
What am I overlooking? I have only rebuilt non-damaged, non-overbored SBCs, I am not an engine builder, I don't really know much about what I'm being told.
454, 4-bolt
Wanting to go to 467 (468 depending on what you want to call it)
Powerplant is going in a street truck/hotrod, will not be raced, will not be a "performance" engine. I want to do 467 because that's what I want to do, but don't have any power requirements or anything like that. This will be a weekend cruisemobile. Building it to take advantage of 1800-3000rpm range. Or something like that...
Shop A comes highly recommended, I've stopped and talked to them, pricing is great, turnaround is great, etc. Told them what I wanted, they said "Ok!"
Shop B also comes highly recommended, more of a race engine shop however. Stopped to chat, told them what I wanted, pricing is great, turnaround is a little slower (not a big deal.) The difference is that they strongly recommended only going .30 over to start. When asked about this, the response was something along the lines of build to .30 over the first time and then when I want to step it up, or when engine needs rebuilding/re-machining, then go .60 over. Something else along the lines of if .30 over goofs up, you still have room to go bigger. If it messes up at .60over, then block is toast, so start smaller then step up later or if problems develop.
Other than $ involved to machine twice, buy two sets of pistons/parts/etc, how much does the rest of their reasoning hold up?
Shouldn't I be comfortable with the machining the first time, from either shop, that the block won't be f'd if I go .60 the first time?
What am I overlooking? I have only rebuilt non-damaged, non-overbored SBCs, I am not an engine builder, I don't really know much about what I'm being told.
