Again sorry for the hijack.
I just am always confused when this comes up.
I guess I am just really dense...
I just cant see why you would flat tow a trail rig instead of just drive it, unless you just cant get it street legal. But even then it would be cheaper to make it street legal than flat tow it around I think.
The only break you could flat tow home safely that you couldnt drive home would be a fatal engine failure, and those are pretty low on the occurence list.
I cant imagine any way the tow vehicle gets better mopg dragging a rig than the rig could get propelling itself, etc.
It's hard to argue any of your points, but there are a couple reasons.
1. Yes, my XJ won't be road legal until I address a couple issues. Granted they're cheap issues, but a pain in the neck to do, so they get put to the bottom of the long list.
2. I can lose any axleshaft, DS, or any powertrain item for that matter and still be able to tow it home-full floating axles.
3. My XJ will more than likely get worse gas mileage than the Blazer towing it. My XJ-when finished-will be rolling with tons and starting with 38's.
4. This one is arguably hypocritical-safety. I feel that flat towing my XJ-which falls into the rated towing capacity of my K5-is safer than driving a heavily modified vehicle on the road. The K5 was designed to be road friendly. While I plan on building some road manners into my 3 and 4 link suspension, it won't be my main focus.
5. My XJ hardly has any room in it for a full weekend of wheeling. My Blazer on the other hand has ample room for me to lay out and sleep if the weather turns foal, tents, coolers, family and/or friends.
6. The XJ with it's prior setup was not fun to drive on a hot day with no A/C and was incredibly loud. K5- not so much. I'm actually surprised by how quiet the cab is with just a fiberglass cap for the rear covering.
I think I've rambled enough. Like I said, it's hard to argue your points in a general sense, but everyone's situation can constitute different reasoning's as to why they did what. But overall I agree with you.