An anaerobic gasket sealer rated for oil contact is the preferred product for this. Permatex, Hylomar, 3Bond, Devcon and some other companies all make products like this, and I believe I've heard that 3Bond makes both Hondabond and the Toyota FIPG. Anaerobics are used in tons of places in OEM assembly, for very good reasons.
The special party trick of anaerobics is that they only cure in the absence of air (that's what anaerobic means) so they will cure between mating surfaces but not in free air, and any uncured liquid can disperse in the oil. Then you won't have RTV blobs in your oil pump. Usually you can put anaerobic-sealed parts into service within a hour or few hours depending on the product and application thickness (that's why OEMs like it, and because of the oil dispersion).
If you use RTV, make sure it's rated for oil contact and let it dry for a day or two before filling with oil. Else you may have blobs of semi-cured RTV in your oil.