Ok I'm at a computer now rather than my Blackcberry.... As a tool dealer I see this all the time. Go to your local school. Here are the reasons.....
1. Simple math: look at what each cost. Figure up that you may get .50 more an hour or at best a $1 to start out. I would take, the last time i checked, about 15,000 hours to make up the difference!!!!! how much time is that???
2. Job placement... Do you want a job here or working in another town or state? Most of the local schools have a good relationship with local shops, in fact alot of shops go to the school for new hires that are teachable(they actually talk to the teachers and find out who has the ability to learn)
3. Work while you learn... Alot of place(mainly dealerships) will hire you on as a lube tech and promote while you are in school and possible cover part of the cost of schools...
Sorry to get on a soapbox but I hate the way both of the schools turn stuff around and make the young men coming through or looking at there programs think its the greatest thing since slice bread. My suggestion would be go talk to the empolyeers that would be your ideal market and ask what they are looking for, heck you may even find one willing to help with the cost of school if you work for them. Feel free to pm if you would like a break down in more detail about the money side, it's really simple if you use your head and a caluclator to do the math and will blow your mind once you do it!!!