I had an XRC8 Comp winch on my Samurai for years, and it got used a lot with zero problems. The main complaint everybody had with them is that they are hard to free spool the line out to due VERY sticky grease inside. The fix is to clean out all the factory sticky grease, and re-grease it with normal wheel bearing type grease. That helped mine tremendously. I believe there was also something about the detent ball for the lever sticking occassionally, and that should be greased as well. I did all that many years ago, so don't remember all the details. I bought mine from 4wheelonline.