Won’t be using wheel spacers anymore

93redzj

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 29, 2005
Location
Albemarle
Well had this happen on the way home today, heard what sounded like metal rubbing metal, there wasn’t any sort of vibration, but it was progressively getting worse. Planned on taking a look once I got home, but this wheel adapter had other plans. Came flying off while going 55mph down the highway. Luckily as I heard it get worse and felt the pop, I had already begun slowing down, once it let go all the way, I managed to pull off the road and come to a sliding stop in the grass. Even luckier though, the tire didn’t collide with any oncoming traffic as it went speeding past me. All I could do was sit and watch as it raced away for about 100 yards before bouncing off a tree and landing in a ditch.
 

Attachments

  • 8EC7CDCD-AC8B-4AB7-801A-90F9C190BE4B.jpeg
    8EC7CDCD-AC8B-4AB7-801A-90F9C190BE4B.jpeg
    259.9 KB · Views: 173
  • E3187F8A-7E56-48A9-B1A0-371A6EC02496.jpeg
    E3187F8A-7E56-48A9-B1A0-371A6EC02496.jpeg
    192 KB · Views: 175
  • DBA202A5-697A-4EBE-8366-FD2DBF761CA6.jpeg
    DBA202A5-697A-4EBE-8366-FD2DBF761CA6.jpeg
    147 KB · Views: 166
Steel spacers are where it's at, fwiw. I've had 2" ones on the back of my HD for about 100,000 miles and tow some heavy stuff with it. 🤷‍♂️ Aluminum has more give to it.
 
But the spacer didn't fail, the axle studs did, correct? Looks like the lugs were loose for a while. Did they have adequate thread engagement and locktite or checked regularly?
I will admit to not checking regularly, although the Jeep has been driven less than 1000 miles in the last year. It’s not a daily driver by any means and when I do take it out it’s usually just around town. And yes it appears it failed on the axle side of things, I’ll fully inspect tomorrow in daylight to see exactly what happened….but I do still wonder if it would have been an issue if the spacers/adapters were not in the picture?
 
I will admit to not checking regularly, although the Jeep has been driven less than 1000 miles in the last year. It’s not a daily driver by any means and when I do take it out it’s usually just around town. And yes it appears it failed on the axle side of things, I’ll fully inspect tomorrow in daylight to see exactly what happened….but I do still wonder if it would have been an issue if the spacers/adapters were not in the picture?
I had a similar failure several years ago. It was the wheel studs on the axle shaft that let go. Probably not torqued right, or just aged studs that may have been overtightened and stretched at some time. A good quality hub-centric spacer is just fine. But on an old truck, I'd be leary of the original studs.
 
@Chris_M seems we have a winner
I've been using spacers for years with stock wheels. I saw the thread and got a twinge of concern. Glad to see spacers weren't the issue. I think most of the bad press they get is from the faults folks have mentioned here. That, and some off brands early on with bad/soft lugs.
 
I have never liked spacers, the math checks when everything is done correctly, BUT it is a component that has a pretty critical failure point that goes unchecked by most of its users.

Glad it all worked out, I have seen more than a few of the aluminum spacers fail, I suspect they are all due a retorque at 50-100 miles of use. Few do the retorque, which is why the kits typically come with red lock tight, which is a poor substitute for torque to spec.
 
it went speeding past me. All I could do was sit and watch as it raced away for about 100 yards before bouncing off a tree and landing in a ditch.
That's a hell of a feeling aint it??
 
Looks like those have been broken for a while.
I sure hope that’s not the case, @Southern_Transplant yeah I had always read horror stories about them failing but never let it stray me away from them, after this though I’ll probably steer clear if I can help it, be it neglect on my part or failure was inevitable, I’d rather not mess with them going forward
 
Cheaper non-hub centric ones will getcha.

I see Ford Super Duty brodozers and squatters with conical lugnuts on huge wheels and that gives me the willies too.
 
2" steel, hub centric spacers from Stahl (sister company to Bora). I've got over 100,000 miles on them. I aint skeered.

20181022_164050.jpg


20200216_093329.jpg
 
Back
Top