I wasn't talking about just the engine here, Seems the 4.0 IS a good engine, it's just the rest of the truck that falls apart around it. And as a whole Toyota's are MUCH more reliable than Jeeps. And I can run a hellofa lot bigger tire than a 35 on my toyota axles, yea I will have to replace the shafts with upgraded ones at a certain point (much larger than 35's), but jeep axles are usually the first thing to get replaced with a stronger WHOLE UNIT, not just upgrading the axle shafts.
Bah, I don't care about the rest of jeeps (don't drive 'em either).
My XJ is a hp d30/8.25 4.0/AW4/NP231
I looked up some stats on the toy 8" and its about as strong as a D44 in most respects (shafts, ring gear), D60 in some places (pinion, more offset easier on R&P altogether). The same is true for the 29 spline chryco 8.25, it has a stiffer housing and pinion shaft than the d44 but slightly smaller axle shafts (d44 shafts same size as yota 8).
Strength isn't the weakness in XJ axles (barring the 35), its aftermarket support.
AW4 is an aisin-warner tranny, and is the same transmission as the A304 that the tuner guys push with 500 hp.
np231 is a chain drive TC, but aren't later yotas too? This is a proven TC to be sure.
So yeah, some jeeps fall apart on you but the NEWEST XJ on the road is 7 years old, and they are all over the place.
I can't believe that no one has mentioned the XJ's main downfall in longevity, the uniframe construction. That can be fixed by making a subframe from u-channel or angle iron. $100 of metal and one afternoon of welding. Also a nice platform for long arms, skids, etc...
My point is more about XJs being cheap and easy and in various places lasting nearly as long, as long, or longer than most yotas. Mine is higher than I'd want it for a DD at 5" on 33s and trimming sheet is definitely easier than an SAS. Yota might be a better hardcore crawler in the end, but the XJ will be easier to build to a trail killer/DD.
Usually when xj jeepers upgrade to new axles its to a d60, ford 9 or 14 bolt. Many look for d44 rear ends to replace the sheisty d35 rear end, and I've even seen a couple toy 8 swaps, but not a ton as it'd be a mostly lateral gain in strength.
There are tons of upgrade axle shafts for jeeps, and most jeepers (not just xjs) will do shafts before a whole swap, but junkyard rears and cheap and certain rear ends are easier/cheaper to swap discs to than others.