bling bling advice needed...

My personal experience... I went just shy of the full carat. .98 looks like a carat, but doesn’t cost as much. Just remember, you will INSTANTLY be judged by every friend that she shows it off to. We were engaged within a month of one of her friends. I watched another mans face lose all color when his fiancée put her diamond up against my wife’s. I’m glad it wasn’t the other way around.
 
First of all, ring envy is selfish bullshit. I don't care what her friend's fiances have wasted on a ring, and neither should she. Spend as much as you feel you want, but don't do it because of what her friends will say.

Second, leave your girl if she judges you based on the ring you get her, because she shouldn't care if she actually loves you. I'm serious. Commitment is not measured in dollars spent on jewelry. If she knows you're going to propose to her, set some ground rules and discuss the useful things that you can do with all that extra money that would otherwise be tied up in some jewelry.

Third, almost all of the stuff related to diamond/ring selection (2 months salary gross, 3 months net, whatever marketing tells you) has been created and promoted by the diamond/jewelry industry to make you buy more expensive stuff. No one actually follows that (I think a month is much more common), and it's a stupid rule based on assumptions that have nothing to do about your financial situation and everything to do about making you spend a lot on a ring. If you have 3 months salary worth of disposable income to spend on a ring, you might want to do something more useful with it than spending it on a ring (my practical opinion).

If you rolled up to a car dealer and they told you that 6 months salary is how much you should spend on a new car, would you make a buying decision based on that, and would you even take them seriously?
 
Last edited:
My personal experience... I went just shy of the full carat. .98 looks like a carat, but doesn’t cost as much. Just remember, you will INSTANTLY be judged by every friend that she shows it off to. We were engaged within a month of one of her friends. I watched another mans face lose all color when his fiancée put her diamond up against my wife’s. I’m glad it wasn’t the other way around.
Haha hell yeah well shit guess I'll just put my mortgage bill stamped on that bad boy in case one of her friends is a bigger ring...
 
First of all, ring envy is selfish bullshit. I don't care what her friend's fiances have wasted on a ring, and neither should she. Spend as much as you feel you want, but don't do it because of what her friends will say.

Second, leave your girl if she judges you based on the ring you get her, because she shouldn't care if she actually loves you. I'm serious. Commitment is not measured in dollars spent on jewelry. If she knows you're going to propose to her, set some ground rules and discuss the useful things that you can do with all that extra money that would otherwise be tied up in some jewelry.

Third, almost all of the stuff related to diamond/ring selection (2 months salary gross, 3 months net, whatever marketing tells you) has been created and promoted by the diamond/jewelry industry to make you buy more expensive stuff. No one actually follows that (I think a month is much more common), and it's a stupid rule based on assumptions that have nothing to do about your financial situation and everything to do about making you spend a lot on a ring. If you have 3 months salary worth of disposable income to spend on a ring, you might want to do something more useful with it than spending it on a ring (my practical opinion).

If you rolled up to a car dealer and they told you that 6 months salary is how much you should spend on a new car, would you make a buying decision based on that, and would you even take them seriously?

Were you that guy in Walmart that day? Dude, I’m sorry mine was bigger. Guess size does matter.
 
Believe I've found a good compromise/choice she gave me tons of examples and told me she didn't want to know what it was! I could probably get her a ring from Walmart and she'd be happy with it but I wanted to have one custom made specific to what she wanted and that's the plan found a guy local and gonna hit him up tom for pricing! This is what Ive come up with except morganite on band and then the actual band will be both diamonds and morganite... should be pretty sweet unless she says no! Haha
 

Attachments

  • IMG_1371.JPG
    IMG_1371.JPG
    48 KB · Views: 180
Appreciate the input nc4x4 never fails!!! Y'all fawking rock! Now for a new thread... lol
 
Most girls want a nice diamond. Some would be fine with a gumball ring but not many. Just get something you know she will like regardless of what others say.

Remember, weddings mean a lot and most especially for the bride. It's your time to spoil her. Don't be a cheap ass as she and everyone if her friends will remind you of it your entire life. :D

Bri wanted a big diamond, blah blah bla. Like everyone else was wearing. I'm not like that and she knows it.

I got an emerald cut diamond and it was awesome. It's unique yet beautiful and it's hard to find at most any store so not many people have it. She gets complimented on it quite often.


So, don't listen to us. Do what you want. Don't over spend but don't be a cheap ass either or you'll regret it forever.
 
Nope, because I don't go to Walmart. :lol:

All joking aside, I bought what I could afford and put a huge smile on my lady’s face. Me nor my wife ever gave a damn what others thought, but we both agree that most women are very judgmental about an engagement ring. Hero or zero at a glance. We’ve been together for 14 years now and that day at Walmart is still a joke we tell. And what’s wrong with Walmart??
 
She stopping by the jewelers tom to see if she's set on morganite so we'll see how that goes lol
 
Third, almost all of the stuff related to diamond/ring selection (2 months salary gross, 3 months net, whatever marketing tells you) has been created and promoted by the diamond/jewelry industry t

Not to mention that the entire market for diamonds is artificial....
 
My focus was in this order: Color, clarity, cut and went with the carat size I could afford within those parameters. Color and clarity are what provide that ‘essential’ sparkle. The whiter the color, the more light will pass through. The cleaner the clarity, the higher the refraction (fewer imperfections to disrupt the light). Then cut emphasizes those, I wanted as symmetrical as possible...a stone cut too deep or too shallow or not square enough will negate the first two I mentioned. The lower any of these are rated is typically what leads to a diamond looking yellowed or dirty or cloudy. From there, I selected the primary, pave and side diamonds from Blue Nile...all loose (all matched specs). Spent a few hours on google to find the setting I liked best, then had Hayes Jeweler in lexington put it all together. Ended up being about $3k cheaper doing it that way than getting the exact same thing premade at a jewelry store, and appraised $6k higher than what I paid (yes I know appraisals are notoriously overstated). That said, if she’s the one...none of this really matters and she’ll love whatever you get her. But those are some key points to keep in mind when operating within whatever your budget is. For me, I was willing to go with smaller diamonds for cleaner diamonds.

35490461-7392-40E6-9DB9-828287AF013C.jpeg
3DA2E770-D343-4C14-A3FC-5747CAC02523.jpeg
 
For the OP
I don't have a ton of advice on the subject. But I will share my engagement ring experience.
My wife isn't a stereotypical woman when it comes to jewelry. I did however spend about $3500 on her ring back in 07. It is a very clear and well cut diamond although not huge in size.
She rarely wears it, but when complimented by her wedding ring, it really looks great.
Buy it from the heart. Maybe even speak to someone one to her and see what she would like in a ring.
Really, like others have said, if she is the one then everything else won't matter and she'll be flattered you want to spend the rest of your life with her.
Congrats man!
 
I️ took my wife with me to pick hers out at diamonds direct. I️ didn’t want to risk picking something she didn’t like, when she is the one wearing it.

I️ told her the budget I️ wanted to spend, roughly 3 months salary, and that the setting and the stone needed to meet that.

We were already talking engagement, and I️ just told her, that she wouldn’t know when/where I️ was going to propose.

Great experience at diamonds direct as we both got to pick out the perfect setting and the best stone we could afford. It was an awesome experience agreeing on what we both liked in a ring. Came in $500 under budget when all said and done.

Her ring was built just for her and makes it special as it wasn’t one already on the shelf and in stock somewhere.
 
Just don't do what I have......If anything took me a while to be decent at it was choices in women. I have bought three of the damn things in my life. One, we never married, my senses came around. Two, a ten year ride to divorce. Three, want be another one. And I am ashamed to say what each cost. But for some reason a got a very decent allowance for each as I shopped the same exact place. My dad spoiled my mom with Jewelry. He also never allowed her to pump gas so when he died I had to teach her. For a long time I thought this was normal. I finally figured out my pops was just selfless and understood finally why he never had money to spend on himself. I don't hate my mom for it. I just know that type of spoiling isn't actually for me. Expensive lesson over too many years. I will say this: if you've spoiled her at all while romanticizing she already has certain expectations. Anything less at any time will bite you in the ass. Ask me how I know! I CAN DEFINITELY sCREW UP dealing with the opposite sex.
 
I will say this: if you've spoiled her at all while romanticizing she already has certain expectations. Anything less at any time will bite you in the ass.

You’re telling me...you guys think I’m an arrogant asshole online, try being married to me. Set that precedent early on, slip up once with a back rub or compliment or a nice surprise, she’ll never let you forget it.

Probably the best tidbit of marriage advice I ever got was: “You’ll never both simultaneously love and want to smother someone with a pillow so much than when you’re married”. And “Whoever has never gone to bed angry is full of shit”.
 
Back
Top