Trying to beef up a bit....

The BMI charts are not fair to those with above average muscle mass.

Body fat percentage does not lie though.
 
VA said I'm 182lbs and have a BMI of 30 yesterday. I asked the doc if I'm ok at that weight and she told me I was just muscular and solid, that I didn't need to get below 175 and it would be hard to lose that weight after it.
 
What other way would you like to non invasively predict health risk?

BMI is a great way to predict health risk(Ie stroke, diabetes, & a host of others) The correlation is there.

BMI is not a health diagnosis and should never be used as such. Also, should not be used as a determination of overall health.

Height and weight charts should be used as a general guideline not the bottom line. Much more important health assessments that should be used. Cholesterol and blood pressure being among those.

Actually....you know that blood cholesterol is now highly contested among mds about its actual relevance to any health factors, right?

And the bmi chart doesn't account for skeleto structure or muscle mass....
 
Cholesterol and blood pressure being among those.

Except for that whole thing where cholesterol and blood pressure levels were found to have no correlation with heart disease.
 
BMI says I'm overweight. Pretty sure @Ron is obese.
 
BMI says I'm overweight. Pretty sure @Ron is obese.

I'm off the charts ..morbidly obese.

Chart would grade above 50% body fat.
Water submersion scales and calipers say high 20s.
Still not fit,but worlds apart
 
Last edited:
I'm off the charts ..morbidly obese.

Chart would grapg oicer 50% body fat.
Water submersion scales and calipers say high 20s.
Still not fit,but worlds apart
Sounds about like me, though I guess most short guys are also not as uh, big boned. Also, I'm not sure what "grapg oicer 50% body fat" is, but it sounds really bad. I hope you get well soon :p
 
damn I hate typing on touch screen shit..but that seems to be the wave o the future.
fixed it.
 
I am 6'0 165lbs and a casual gym enthusiast. I can't go more than 3 days without working out in some manner otherwise I feel off, both physically and mentally.

But I did get a large curly fry for lunch, so... yeah.

I am the same way. I will get edgy and irritable if I go more than a few days without exerting myself physically.
 
BMI chart states that I am morbidly obese @ 320 lbs on my 6'7" frame....yes, my belly is round, but blood pressure is low, function 10 -12 hours a work day with out being gassed.

BMI seems to be merely a rough idea....tells me to be around 240. Lowest I have been in many years was 260 on chemo.

I want to be back under 300, say around 290....no mo' mountain dew. Sad face.
 
BMI chart states that I am morbidly obese @ 320 lbs on my 6'7" frame....yes, my belly is round, but blood pressure is low, function 10 -12 hours a work day with out being gassed.

BMI seems to be merely a rough idea....tells me to be around 240. Lowest I have been in many years was 260 on chemo.

I want to be back under 300, say around 290....no mo' mountain dew. Sad face.

Your a big mofo, that is all.
 
Your a big mofo, that is all.


image.jpg
 
Back
Top