Mind sharing the pros and cons. Was planning to run a softtopper on my 4runner
I believe the softopper for the 4Runner will be a little different than what I’m working with for just a truck bed but here’s what I’ve noticed.
The first difference I see between the two is how everything seals up. The side rails and cab end of the top seal to the bed in a similar manor for the two brands, but the way the canvas seals to the side rails and tailgate are very different. The bestop folds into the rails just like a Jeep top does where as the softopper just snaps to the rails. At the tailgate, the bestop has a “rail” type insert that slides through the back window, (again similar but different design as the softopper) but the bestop has a rubber seal that sits on the top of the tailgate like a door seal. The softopper does not, it has a longer flap that hangs lower over the top of the tailgate to keep out rain. The overall design allows the bestop to keep out more dust than the softopper will ever dream about doing.
I believe both tops will keep out most water but over the softopper will leak more elements into the bed the way it’s designed. The bestop allowed some stuff in but it definitely had a better overall seal to the bed.
The top portion of the canopy on the softopper seems to be designed in a better way to keep the fabric tight and has adjustability to keep it tight. The bestop did not and on hot days driving on the highway, the fabric would stretch allowing the mid section to cave in a bit.
The back window on the softopper seems to be a little more floppy when in the full enclosed position. There is adjustment in this area and I plan to play with it a little more, but this will also create a larger gap between the tailgate and the flap that hangs down which will allow more road dust to be sucked up in the bed.
The softopper is about 2” higher than the cab and you can see how large the gap is between the top of the cab and the softtop. Bestop seemed to fit better here also.
The softopper with windows rolled up is much nicer than how the bestop performed the same task. You had to remove the windows from the bestop and store them somewhere. When doing this the bestop still had fabric from the canopy section down to the bedrail which catches a lot of wind and created a strain on the top when driving. Softopper has solved that issue.
I like the top, just wish this model was a little more specific for my truck than it seems to be. Looking at the invoice this top part number covers all 6’ bed Toyota trucks from 2004 and back as well as the Nissan Frontier.