Southern_Transplant
Comic Relief
- Joined
- Nov 13, 2019
- Location
- Fayetteville, NC
Two points you make are spot on.I think perhaps fully privatizing school, take it out of government hands, could be a great option. If parents have skin in the game then it won’t be thought of as free daycare. Parents might push their kids to do well. I know most here probably helped their kids to do well in school but trust me that a huge % do not. I have worked with families that had absolutely no interest in how their kids did, none. My program had some success in changing that, we absolutely did, but some just saw what we did as an extension of the free daycare itself.
Taxes are ground up in unnecessary positions and programs that more efficient private businesses would streamline. More successful schools would drive competitive systems of learning instead of the grind of mandatory and largely poorly thought out standards. Teachers would be the best, not those with longevity status.
For lowest income students some kind of partial assistance % could be subsidized but still require a minimum investment of the parents. I know of no parents paying for private school (and I’m not talking wealthy families but families that decided education of their kids is important enough to sacrifice for) who don’t push their kids to do well.
My probably most controversial idea would be to not be so eager to push all kids into college. Some that have a proclivity for trades or others who simply do not have the drive or will to succeed in higher learning could learn to be productive and make a good living doing unglamorous but necessary jobs. By 10th grade it is getting obvious which students desire more education or at the least are capable if helped. For some students, going all the way to grade 12 at 18yo (or older for some) is simply a waste of time that could be spent learning something that will actually prepare the student for real life.
1) College is not for every person or for every trade. It has been mentioned several times here that we should be pushing kids towards practical jobs that are needed to make life 'go'. You don't need a college degree to be an HVAC Technician but you do need advanced skills.
2) Involved parents and chosen schools are high indicators of success. You will not get the US (or any established society) to cancel public education. But I advocate for vouchers and magnet/charter public schools. We pushed my son in to an early college program for highschool. It was free. At the end of the program, he will have his associates degree in computer science and some certifications in network security and programming. The one thing you can see in every kid in that program is a parent that has skin in the game. You have to at least be willing to drop your kid off in the morning (no morning bus service). Plus, if you don't help your kid they fail the program in the first year. It's just a lot of work for a 14 y.o. to take college classes.