You can go for the ad hominem, it won't hurt my feelings. But I think you misunderstand me. Fundamentally, I'm a cheap ass. I'm going to avoid half measures because they cost money, not because I'm anxious to buy top shelf parts.
If you say you decided to pay $200 for a tarp so your butt doesn't get wet, you'd better be able to back it up with facts more substantial than "I'm glad I spent so much monies!!!" Here at the house, I have an OEM top, a Bestop (they make OEM, btw), and a Smittybilt. I've never looked at any of them and thought, "Man, this fabric is pretty shitty, I wish I had a top made out of unicorn hide." Maybe the unicorn hide imparts magical powers to the vehicle. I wouldn't know, because I've never had a unicorn hide soft top. But if you buy a unicorn hide soft top and post a build thread about how glad you are that you traded your firstborn son for a unicorn hide soft top, you'd better be prepared to impart some wisdom to the populace about all the magical shit your Jeep is now capable of doing.
Absent the knowledge of what I'm missing out with the unicorn hide soft top, I'll stick with a $65 open box from Amazon. My ass is dry either way.